Sourdough failure

We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post, at no additional cost to you.

Well, my sourdough experiment didn’t work. I had such high hopes for it!

When I mixed up the dough today and left it to rise, it didn’t rise very far before it started to crack. It was sitting for several hours, but I was concerned it would dry out too much. I preheated the oven and baked it.

Yuck. It smelled good, and the first bite tasted ok. But it was too dense, the crust was too crunchy, and was way too sour.

I’ve been trying to figure out where I went wrong with it. Some things I think should be fixable. The others will probably take more experimentation.

After my sourdough rose so much the first few days, I dumped off most of the liquid that had formed. That might have been my first mistake, because after that, my starter barely rose at all. I considered dumping the starter and starting over, but figured I’d keep feeding it to see how it did. Now I’m thinking I should’ve just tried again. Oh well.

The really dense texture I know was caused by not enough rise time. That’s easily remedied. Maybe covering the dough with plastic wrap next time will help with it not drying out so quickly.

The really crisp crust I think was caused by over baking it. That doesn’t make sense to me. The instructions I followed said to bake it at 350 for an hour. Most breads I bake at 350 for a half hour, so I checked the bread at 20 minutes. Firm crust, soggy middle. I put it in for 20 minutes more. Crisp crust and still a soggy middle. I took it out at that point because I was afraid of how crunchy the finished loaf would be.

The sourness I knew would be a gamble. I now know that we don’t like our bread quite so sour, and will work on making a thicker starter as Laura described.

So now I have three loaves of very sour sourdough bread that I’m not sure what to do with. Stephen said to slather it with butter and jam and eat it that way. I’m wondering if it’s good for much more than croutons. If only we ate croutons more often (almost never around here!). Anyone have any suggestions? There’s so much flour invested in it that I’d hate to just throw it out.

That said, I’m debating how long to wait to try making the starter again. I kept this starter, but I’d like to try starting from scratch to see if the outcome is any different. I sure hope so. The bread smelled SO GOOD baking that it’d be a shame to not be able to figure out how to make it the right way!

Spread the love

7 thoughts on “Sourdough failure”

  1. If all else fails, feed to a neighbor’s dog! LOL!! I really don’t know what else to recommend. We don’t like sour dough bread here, so I’m not sure. I was excited about how you were making this recipe. Oh Well…

  2. Mary Lou, thanks! We usually use oatmeal in our meatballs, but the breadcrumbs are a great idea.

    Michelle, that recipe sounds fairly similar to my father-in-law’s stuffing/dressing. I hadn’t thought of that, but my family would LOVE that! Thanks!

  3. Here’s a recipe from an Amish cookbook (The Best of Amish Cooking by Phyllis Pellman Good). I haven’t tried it, but it sounds good and easy.

    Chicken Roast
    1.5 loaves of homemade bread
    1 lb of butter or margarine
    1 1/2 teaspoon salt
    1/2 teaspoon pepper
    1 teaspoon celery seed
    3/4 cup celery, chopped (optional)
    meat from a whole chicken, stewed and removed from bones

    Crumble bread by hand into large mixing bowl. Melt butter then pour over bread crumbs. Add the seasonings and chopped celery. Then mix with the deboned chicken chunks. Turn into large roast pan and bake covered at 350* for half hour to an hour, until heated through. Dampen with water around the edges if it begins to dry out. Stir often to prevent sticking. Note: you may make a rich gravy to serve over the roast by thickening the chicken broth with flour.

  4. Do you make meatballs or meat loaf? Breaded anything? Cut the loaf that was left out last night in half with a bread knife. Allow it to dry out until it is crusty hard. Throw it in the food processor if you have one or in a ziploc bag and pound into ……fine bread crumbs. Add some herbs for seasoning and put into a freezer safe container. When you need bread crumbs……you have them all ready to use! That is what I do with any of my old bread so that I don’t waste it.

  5. LOL Stephanie!

    I made a ham sandwich with it this morning, and aside from the hard crust, it tasted pretty good. Sam, on the other hand, ate TWO peanut butter and jelly sandwiches from it! Caleb ate an entire jelly sandwich too! Guess I don’t have to worry about the kids liking it! I was absolutely shocked.

    The one loaf might still become croutons though. I forgot to wrap it and it’s REALLY hard now, lol!

  6. I say make the croutons! I love them things great for salad and just about anything. I am strange I like to eat them out of the bag sometimes lol. The whole butter slattering would also work it makes anything taste good.

Comments are closed.

Scroll to Top